Expedia vs Hotels.com in New York
Mid-Manhattan hotels carry the highest premium per square foot of any major US city — even a basic 3-star inside Times Square rarely dips below £200/night. Stays in Brooklyn (Williamsburg, DUMBO) or Long Island City often run 30–40% cheaper with a 15-minute subway ride to Midtown via the L or 7 lines. The Financial District has become a value play since the post-2020 office-to-hotel conversions, and weekends there are especially soft. Avoid early December through New Year (rates double for the tree-lighting and holiday window) and the UN General Assembly week in September. JFK to Manhattan is fastest via AirTrain + LIRR (40 minutes) rather than the subway (90 minutes); cabs run £55–90 with congestion pricing now in effect. The CityPASS pays back after three major museums or attractions. Headline rate in New York runs £180–£540/night — both sites pull from the same inventory, so the price you see for a given property is almost always the same. Differences come from coupon stacking and member-only rates.
Search New York on both partners
Search New York on Expedia Group partners
Final price, availability and cancellation policy are determined by the merchant. We earn a commission when you complete a booking, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Which site to use for New York
- Just want the cheapest hotel — check both; cheapest wins. Coupon promotions in New York typically run on one site or the other (rarely both), so a 30-second compare often saves £5–£15/night.
- Adding flights from the UK — Expedia. Their flight + hotel package to New York typically saves 10–30% versus booking separately.
- Wanting full cancellation flexibility — Hotels.com's "Fully refundable" filter is faster to apply at the results-page level. Both sites honour the same merchant policies once you book.
- Want activities in New York too — Expedia carries tours and experiences for New York in the same booking flow. Hotels.com doesn't.
Top picks in New York
- Central Park
- MoMA
- Brooklyn Bridge walk
Background on Expedia vs Hotels.com
Both sites are owned by Expedia Group and share inventory. The difference is the storefront — search filters, sort defaults, loyalty surfacing. We covered the full side-by-side in our flagship Expedia vs Hotels.com comparison.